PainScience.com Sensible advice for aches, pains & injuries
 
 

Get in the Pool for Pain

Aquatic therapy, aquajogging, water yoga, floating and other water-based treatment and injury rehab options

updated
by Paul Ingraham, Vancouver, Canadabio
I am a science writer and a former Registered Massage Therapist with a decade of experience treating tough pain cases. I was the Assistant Editor of ScienceBasedMedicine.org for several years. I’ve written hundreds of articles and several books, and I’m known for readable but heavily referenced analysis, with a touch of sass. I am a runner and ultimate player. • more about memore about PainScience.com

Anyone with almost any kind of chronic pain should consider spending more time in the pool (doing almost anything, but aquajogging is a particularly good choice).1 This includes many patients who may not normally think of pool therapy.

Aquatic therapy can be great for almost any kind of stubborn pain. Immersion and floatation have curiously potent benefits. The partial relief from gravity, that most relentless of all physical stresses, is valuable both as actual mechanical security and to make movement feel easy, cushioned, and safe — and feeling safer with movement can be a critical stepping stone in all kinds of rehabilitation and pain management. Modern pain science has makes it clear that pain is an expression of perceived danger to the system.2 Pools are one of the few places where we can both be more active while also actually feeling safer. That’s a precious combination. There are some other helpful biological effects of immersion, too: the human nervous system really seems to like it.

But it’s not magic: studies have shown it’s no better than “dry” rehab for most problems.34 It’s not for everyone, and there are some downsides, like getting chilly (a deal-breaker for some chronic pain patients). However, it is well worth taking a shot at it and making the effort to make it work for you.5

Floating (deep and shallow)

The simplest aquatic therapy is to just float. There are two main kinds of floatation therapy:

All of the above is potentially terrific for injury rehabilitation and chronic pain in many ways.

Just immersing yourself can lower your heart rate and has curiously profound neurological effects.

Aquajogging and water aerobics: don’t just float there, do something!

Aquajogging and water aerobics combine the benefits of vertical (deep) immersion with exercise, “the closest thing there is to a miracle cure.”11

The lack of impact, the “cushioning,” and the ease of fine-tuning the intensity make it a fine place for garden variety rehab. But where aquatic therapy may shine brightest is with patients whose primary symptom is unexplained pain, like fibromyalgia.12 I’m not saying that the pool has any special properties that directly treat complex and chronic pain — although that is also possible — just that immersion facilitates exercise in patients that both particularly need it and struggle with it (a difficult benefit to measure).

Aquajogging works a lot better with the help of a simple accessory, a buoyancy belt like the AquaJogger or the WaterGym Water Float Belt (and many others, sometimes called a water aerobics belt). I recently encountered a fellow who was wearing one of these at the pool, and he claimed he’d had his for more than a decade: a good investment!

Oddly enough, I’d never heard of aquajogging until quite recently. Reader Jared Updike introduced me to it in 2016. He’s a persuasive evangelist for it:

I would love for more people to know about aquajogging. It is a weirdly convenient form of swimming where you trade several pieces of equipment (goggles, hair cap, ear plugs, etc.) for a single strange piece of equipment (flotation belt) and in exchange your hair and eyes and ears stay dry and you can wear a hat and sunglasses while you slowly pull yourself across the pool. And it scales up or down for different fitness levels or pain-level fluctuations. It’s the closest thing to a silver bullet I have found for my pain and fatigue.

Read a more detailed guide to aquajogging.

Or you could just, you know, swim! Swimming itself is, of course, great exercise. If your body will tolerate it, it’s one of the best workouts you can do. But for chronic pain patients, the vertical immersion of aquajogging really is ideal.

Water Yoga: 5 breathing and stretching exercises for the water

The popularity of yoga is almost oppressive. People feel that they “should” try yoga and may even feel guilty for not trying it (or not liking it). For people on the fence, a little water yoga might be more fun and easier to mess around with. 😃

I use a pool regularly for “yoga” rather than for swimming — a casual and unstructured yoga, but yoga nevertheless. Using the buoyancy of water to aid rehabilitation is a well-known and excellent idea, but the potential for your pool to be an excellent place to breathe and stretch is less widely appreciated. Here are five examples of exercises that make good use of the water:

Complicated diagram of a torso submerged in water, showing how water exerts a pressure of 1 pound per square inch on all the surface area of the adomen, resisting inhalation.

The physics of water breathing

Water pressure resists expansion of the abdomen uniformly on all sides — and therefore it resists diaphragm contraction.

  1. Diaphragmatic breathing. Water pressure is surprisingly strong even just a couple feet down. This provides strong resistance to abdominal expansion… and you can seriously dial up the diaphragm workout by adding a snorkel or longer breathing tube and sinking just a little further into the water, thanks to the magic of pressure math.13 Note that there are some safety issues here, so please be sensible.14 A nice variation is to do an abdominal lift or lock exercise (uddiyana bandha).
  2. Floating forward bend, a watered-down version (ha ha!) of the big toe pose (padangusthasana, similar to the better-known simple standing forward bend or uttanasana). Simply take a deep breath — your head will be underwater! — and fold in half at the waist, grasp your big toes, and pull your head down towards your knees. You will bob like a cork as you stretch!
  3. The bow pose (dhanurasana) is much more comfortable in a pool than when you are fighting gravity — the strength required to get into and sustain these poses can make it unpleasant. In the pool, you can enjoy the best sensations the pose has to offer … and you can be even more bow-like. (Bow-ish? Bowly? Bowed?) Take a good deep breath — you will may need hold the air in your lungs to float high enough in the water — reach down and pull one leg up behind you by the ankle, then the other, and then arch your back. Let your air-filled chest keep you afloat.15
The bow pose<br> (landlubber’s version): Or <em>dhanurasana</em> in Sanscrit. Thanks to <a href="http://www.yogajournal.com/poses/875">YogaJournal.com</a> for the image. They have <a href="http://www.yogajournal.com/poses/finder/browse_categories">a well-presented selection of yoga poses</a> — though none of them is in the water!

The bow pose
(landlubber’s version)

Or dhanurasana in Sanscrit. Thanks to YogaJournal.com for the image. They have a well-presented selection of yoga poses — though none of them is in the water!

  1. Dead float. Nothing beats floating for deep relaxation. A watery version of yoga’s corpse pose (savasana), floating perfectly still is lovely. Of course this works best if you’re nice and warm after a session in the hot tub, and a really great refinement is to have a partner slightly support you and move you around in the water. Do be aware that someone may think you are drowning!16
  2. Sinking meditation. Okay, perhaps I’m kinda weird — undoubtedly I am — but I think it’s really neat to sink to the bottom of the pool and meditate while holding my breath. Yes, I really do this. No, they aren’t long meditations! But I’m a busy guy and I don’t like long meditations anyway. Pool bottoms are peaceful places, and slowly sinking to the bottom is a strong metaphor for descent into an altered state. For the best results, you have to do something counterintuitive: you have to exhale most of your breath, and hold your breath at the bottom (in two senses). This may seem alien at first, but it works better than you think it will. I’ve been practicing this for a long time, and it’s no problem for me to do a couple minutes.17

Yoga and stretching are not everything they are cracked up to be, and they probably fail to achieve much of what people are hoping for — such as preventing muscle soreness,18 or curing low back pain.19 But I am not anti-stretching: it feels great, and not only is that sufficient reason in itself, it probably does mean it’s doing something valuable for us biologically, even if it’s surprisingly unclear exactly what. Here’s an interesting clue: a 2011 study showed that a program of static stretching alone — just pulling on muscles — had a clear benefit for heart rate regulation, a common way of measuring fitness.20 Bodies probably need constant sensory feedback for optimum function — use it or lose it — and this evidence is probably a nice demonstration of that principle.


About Paul Ingraham

Headshot of Paul Ingraham, short hair, neat beard, suit jacket.

I am a science writer, former massage therapist, and I was the assistant editor at ScienceBasedMedicine.org for several years. I have had my share of injuries and pain challenges as a runner and ultimate player. My wife and I live in downtown Vancouver, Canada. See my full bio and qualifications, or my blog, Writerly. You might run into me on Facebook or Twitter.

Related Reading

What’s new in this article?

MarchScience updated. Added a couple key citations about the efficacy of aquatic therapy, and spelling out the case for it a bit more.

FebruaryAdded a footnote with some tips about how to cope with getting chilly in pools.

Notes

  1. Swim England is all about promoting swimming, so it’s hardly an unbiased source on this topic, but I don’t really doubt the very positive gist of the findings of a 2017 report they commissioned:

    The report particularly highlights the benefits of swimming and aquatic activities for people with mental health concerns or problems with their joints and muscles.

    BACK TO TEXT
  2. Modern pain science shows that pain is an unpredictable sensation thoroughly tuned by the brain and not as closely related to tissue trouble as most people assume. So can we think pain away? Probably not, but we may be able to influence it. For more information, see Pain is Weird: Pain science reveals a volatile, misleading sensation that is often more than just a symptom, and sometimes worse than whatever started it. BACK TO TEXT
  3. Villalta EM, Peiris CL. Early aquatic physical therapy improves function and does not increase risk of wound-related adverse events for adults after orthopedic surgery: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2013 Jan;94(1):138–48. PubMed #22878230.

    A review of 8 tests of aquatic physical therapy after orthopedic surgeries found that it was safe and at least as effective as land-based therapy. Unfortunately, it showed no superiority for swelling and pain, benefits that might be needed justify the cost and hassle.

    BACK TO TEXT
  4. Barker AL, Talevski J, Morello RT, et al. Effectiveness of aquatic exercise for musculoskeletal conditions: a meta-analysis. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2014 Sep;95(9):1776–86. PubMed #24769068.

    A review of 26 tests of aquatic therapy for miscellaneous musculoskeletal conditions. The results are similar to Villalta et al (for rehab after surgical): at least as good as land-based therapy, but no better (alas).

    BACK TO TEXT
  5. Try different pools — they aren’t all the same temperature! Call and ask (there’s usually a temperature every facility aims for). And consider a wetsuit. Such solutions might sound like overkill, but what’s worse: buying and maintaining a wetsuit or two? Driving a little? Or abandoning an excellent treatment option for your chronic pain? (Hat tip to reader Jared Updike for these suggestions — I wholeheartedly agree.) BACK TO TEXT
  6. Cuesta-Vargas A, Garcia-Romero JC, Kuisma R. Maximum and Resting Heart Rate in Treadmill and Deep-Water Running in Male International Volleyball Players. International Journal of Aquatic Research and Education. 2009;3:398–405.

    In this simple test of several volleyball players, running in water resulted in a much lower maximum heart rate and recovery heart rate than running on a treadmill: a clear “cardiovascular response mediated by immersion in water.”

    BACK TO TEXT
  7. Mourot L, Teffaha D, Bouhaddi M, et al. Exercise rehabilitation restores physiological cardiovascular responses to short-term head-out water immersion in patients with chronic heart failure. J Cardiopulm Rehabil Prev. 2010;30(1):22–7. PubMed #20068419.

    In patients with coronary artery disease, short-term head-out water immersion had several significant effects on circulatory function, especially, including a significantly decreased pulse rate, both before and after a rehabilitation program. Patients with chronic heart failure were initially unaffected by immersion, but “restored the usual central responses.” Arterial compliance was the only hemodynamic factor that was not affected by immersion.

    BACK TO TEXT
  8. Schipke JD, Pelzer M. Effect of immersion, submersion, and scuba diving on heart rate variability. Br J Sports Med. 2001 Jun;35(3):174–80. PubMed #11375876. PainSci #53699.

    Heart rate variability (HRV) refers to the slight wobbles in the rhythm of the heart, tiny variations in the time between beats. Curiously, this is a good indicator of neurological relaxation or arousal, messy and complex but reliable. For this test, HRV was measured in twenty-five scuba divers were tested in head-out immersion and while diving in a pool (27˚C). They found that “all HRV measures showed an increase in the parasympathetic activity” (relaxation) and “immersion under pool conditions is a powerful stimulus for both the sympathetic and parasympathetic nervous system.” Fascinating!

    BACK TO TEXT
  9. Epsom salt in your bath is cheap and harmless and it makes bath water feel “silkier,” so there’s no reason to ban it from your life. However, it probably doesn’t do what you hope it’s doing. Although Epsom salt probably does have some physiological effects, it is unknown if there is a therapeutic effect on aches and pains … and somewhat unlikely. Most of the theories you hear are oversimplified and meaningless — for instance, nearly everyone says it is absorbed by osmosis, but that is false and impossible — and the known effects of Epsom salt don’t have much to do with common causes of pain. The heat of a nice bath is probably more therapeutic. The case for the healing powers of Epsom salt is mostly made by people selling the stuff, or recommending it as casually and imprecisely as an old wives’ tale. See Does Epsom Salt Work? The science of Epsom salt bathing for recovery from muscle pain, soreness, or injury. BACK TO TEXT
  10. Although a quiet, dark floatation tank certainly deprives us of our normal sensations, by no means are we actually deprived. It actually constitutes a pleasant, novel sensory experience, not “deprivation.” BACK TO TEXT
  11. Academy of Medical Royal Colleges. Exercise: The miracle cure and the role of the doctor in promoting it. AOMRC.org.uk. 2015 Feb. PainSci #53672.

    ABSTRACT


    The big four “proximate” causes of preventable ill-health are: smoking, poor nutrition, lack of physical activity and alcohol excess. Of these, the importance of regular exercise is the least well-known. Relatively low levels of increased activity can make a huge difference. All the evidence suggests small amounts of regular exercise (five times a week for 30 minutes each time for adults) brings dramatic benefits. The exercise should be moderate – enough to get a person slightly out of breath and/or sweaty, and with an increased heart rate. This report is a thorough review of that evidence.

    Regular exercise can prevent dementia, type 2 diabetes, some cancers, depression, heart disease and other common serious conditions — reducing the risk of each by at least 30%. This is better than many drugs.

    BACK TO TEXT
  12. Fibromyalgia is extremely difficult to treat, but exercising in the goldilocks zone is the first line of defense. The pool is ideal in many ways. BACK TO TEXT
  13. The weight of the water presses relentlessly inwards on every square inch of rib cage and belly, and the narrow diameter of the tube becomes the sole pressure outlet for the weight of all that water. Air whooshes out of your lungs and through the tube, unless you stop it. Put your tongue over the tube end, and you will notice a formidable suction. When you try to inhale through that tube, you have to first match the suction and then exceed it to get any air! It becomes well nigh impossible as you descend. For a more detail description of the physics, see the exercises at the end of the article The Respiration Connection. BACK TO TEXT
  14. Blazingly obvious, disclaimery safety warnings: I am not responsible for you being foolish in the water. Don’t do this alone. Don’t do this in deep water. Don’t use too long/wide a tube for too long. Don’t keep going if you feel dizzy or nauseous. Don’t inhale water. Don’t chew gum while you’re doing this. Et cetera, et cetera. BACK TO TEXT
  15. Although I mostly hold my breath to stay afloat, I find I can take quick breaths to sustain the pose. If I let out too much air for too long, though, I sink! Your mileage may vary. BACK TO TEXT
  16. Reader George Ingham, formerly a lifeguard, tells me that “sometimes people would do a dead float without telling me about it,” resulting in embarrassing “rescues”! BACK TO TEXT
  17. Almost unbelievably, as of early 2010, the world record for breath-holding was 19 minutes and 21 seconds. The previous record holder about 17 minutes before that. I had a client who was an elite free diver, who regularly held her breath for about 6-7 minutes, and hung out with people who were getting to 8. Wow. BACK TO TEXT
  18. A large 2011 review of all the available science to date concluded with a clear thumbs down: “The evidence from randomised studies suggests that muscle stretching, whether conducted before, after, or before and after exercise, does not produce clinically important reductions in delayed-onset muscle soreness in healthy adults.” See Herbert, or see my main stretching article for a lot more information like that: Quite a Stretch: Stretching science shows that a stretching habit isn’t doing much of what people hope. BACK TO TEXT
  19. At best, yoga is probably no more than slightly better than nothing as a low back pain treatment — and a pair of studies found that yoga classes conveyed no more benefit than ordinary stretching and exercise classes, which was a bit of a blow to yoga pride. See Sherman et al. BACK TO TEXT
  20. Farinatti PT, Brandão C, Soares PP, Duarte AF. Acute effects of stretching exercise on the heart rate variability in subjects with low flexibility levels. J Strength Cond Res. 2011 Jun;25(6):1579–85. PubMed #21386722.

    This study of stretching found that

    multiple-set flexibility training sessions enhanced the vagal modulation and sympathovagal balance [that’s good] in the acute postexercise recovery, at least in subjects with low flexibility levels. … stretching routines may contribute to a favorable autonomic activity change in untrained subjects.

    This seems like a fairly straightforward bit of good-news science about stretching. It’s not a surprising idea that movement would have some systemic regulatory effects (motion is lotion, use it or lose it), but it’s nice to see some corroboration of that common sensical notion, and it’s also nice to know that perhaps just stretching did this (to the extent we can learn anything from a single study). If true, it makes for nice evidence to support a general stretching habit, yoga, mobilizations, really any kind of “massaging with movement,” and probably even massage itself.

    BACK TO TEXT