Placebo enthusiasm cannot be curbed
PainSci Member Login
Submit your email to unlock this audio content (and any other stuff for members). If you can’t remember or access your registration email, please contact me. ~ Paul Ingraham, PainSci Publisher
Found! 🙂 Member content on this page only has just been unlocked. To unlock member content on all other pages, see the confirmation email just sent. (If it doesn’t turn up in your inbox, check your spam folder! Email can also sometimes take a few minutes. If it never turns up, just contact me.)
Found, but… you are not an active PainSci member, so this content cannot be unlocked. See your confirmation email for more information about your account.
Not found! 🙁 Sorry, but that email address is not in the PainSci database.
⚠️ Sorry, too many lookups right now. This is a rare error. It should go away if you try again in a little bit.
Privacy & Security of this form This login is private and secure: the information you submit is encrypted, used only to search for matching accounts, and then discarded.
Enthusiasm for the power and mystique of placebo is like the mole in Whack-A-Mole: curb it over here, and it just pops up somewhere else! I get pushback whenever I share anything about how placebo isn’t actually all that exotic or potent — like this study showing placebo does almost nothing for back pain, which I shared on Facebook a couple weeks ago. Someone invariably responds with their favourite “is so powerful!” example … which, so far, has never persuaded me to renounce my skepticism and start worshipping the power of placebo.
For instance, there’s the whole placebo-without-deception thing… which isn’t really a thing at all.
Or the animal thing: I have lost count of the times someone has responded to a bummer about placebo with “yeah, but dogs and horses aren’t affected by it, so it must be an impressive example of the power and weirdness of the human mind.” Bzzzz, nope, thank you for playing!
Trying to debunk the power of placebo is like trying to debunk ice cream. People are determined to be in awe of placebo. And I get it: we all badly want a bit of magic to be left in this world (please), and placebo seems like a decent candidate. So people have latched onto it, drawn to something a wee bit magical — but unfortunately that’s mostly just based on some misleading old hype. It’s essentially a form of superstition, a manifestation of the belief that things are stranger than they actually are.
And it’s always easy to avoid messy, boring truths.
If there’s a way to convince people placebo is not all it’s cracked up to be, it’s education, of course. Superstition is just the misplaced awe of the ignorant. We must learn enough to be amazed by the genuine marvels of science. We must be nerds! We must be fascinated by that which requires lots of hard work to understand, and would otherwise be opaque and boring.
You can read more about placebo power hype on PainScience.com, of course.