PainScience.com Sensible advice for aches, pains & injuries
 
 
x

The Pain & Therapy Bibliography, Record ID 0582

Inside chiropractic: a patient’s guide


page updated

summary

The preface to Sam Homola’s polemic against chiropractic is almost poetry: a clear, rational, satisfying summary of complex subject that feels like the last word.


item type
a page in a book
author
Samuel Homola
 
Buy this book from
editor
Stephen Barrett
publisher
Prometheus Books
year
1999
page
p. vii
the nugget
Although progress has been made, the [chiropractic] profession still has one foot lightly planted in science and the other firmly rooted in cultism. Without appropriate criticism, the good in chiropractic will never be sifted out, and competent chiropractors will not receive the recognition they deserve.

excerpt

Chiropractic, which celebrated its centennial in 1995, is a curious mixture of science and pseudoscience, sense and nonsense. Much of it is based on the theory that misaligned spinal bones produce nerve interference that causes disease. Many chiropractors claim that correcting these misalignments (“subluxations”) can restore health and that regular spinal adjustments are essential to maintain it.

Neither logic nor scientific evidence supports such a belief. Although spinal manipulation can relieve certain types of back pain, neck pain, and other musculoskeletal symptoms, there is no scientific evidence that it can restore or maintain health. As a result of expressing my opinion on this subject, I have been called a chiropractic heretic.

The chiropractic profession has little tolerance for dissension. Its nonsense remains unchallenged by its leaders and has not been denounced in its journals. In fact, many chiropractic journals continue to publish articles that attempt to justify subluxation theory. Although progress has been made, the profession still has one foot lightly planted in science and the other firmly rooted in cultism. Without appropriate criticism, the good in chiropractic will never be sifted out, and competent chiropractors will not receive the recognition they deserve.

This book denounces the cultism in chiropractic but supports the appropriate use of spinal manipulation and the research efforts required to solidify its scientific basis. If you are contemplating or receiving chiropractic care, it might help protect both your pocketbook and your health.

related content

PS Review of Inside Chiropractic: A Patient’s Guide, a book by Samuel Homola — Homola’s book the perfect guide if you like spinal adjustment but you’re wary of chiropractic controversies

One article on PainScience.com cites this item as a source: